Yesterday, I was hanging out with a couple buddies of mine who are Wargaming Enthusiasts.   In some circles, particularly 40k and Fantasy, they have been called ‘beardy’.  So I tend to approach their army lists with a little bit of skepticism and I should have known better when Dan purchased 3 boxes of Warlord Games Scorpion Batteries.  So Dan and Steve start their game.

Steve was playing his EIR, with 2 heavy bolt-throwers and a stone thrower, which is a typical build for him.  Dan on the other hand has been building a Later Achaemenid Persian army, I knew he had purchased the bolt-throwers but what I saw on the table was monstrous.  In his 2500 point army list, he had included 7 bolt-throwers.  My initial thoughts were that the list was unbalanced and pretty WAAC (win at all costs).  It was as the game progressed that I realized that the 7 bolt-throwers (arranged into 3 batteries) were less effective than the stone thrower (by itself).  It came down to the fact that Steve is a master of guess range weapons, while Dan had to rely on dice.  Don’t get me wrong, the bolt-throwers did wipe out a unit of legionnaires by themselves, but in the end it was a solid win for the Romans, who prevailed against 7 bolt-throwers and over 125 bow armed models.  I initially thought the Later Persian army list in Armies of Antiquity 2 had a large whole in it with the amount of bolt-throwers which could be included, those thoughts have been dispelled.

The important point was their game was average, with average dice rolls and expected combat results.  The 2 units of legionnaires which reached the massed Kardakes, mopped them up without much effort, once the army began to break, it became a rapid disintegration.  It was a great game and both guys are top notch players, I am glad I have seen the Persian Bolt-Thrower Madness in action and now know it is much more bark than bite.

Advertisements

One thought on “Persian Bolt-Thrower Madness!

  1. Great wrap up; I like stone throwers for the same reason – althought I’m not good at guessing ranges – I rather rely on this than die rolls.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s